Agenda
Joint Meeting
Committee on Regional Electric Power Cooperation
and
State-Provincial Steering Committee

Westin Hotel

San Diego, California

 April 3-4, 2012

Schedule of Meetings 
 

Tuesday 
April 3, 2012

Wednesday 
April 4, 2012

8:00 a.m. - 5:15 p.m. 
Joint CREPC / SPSC Meeting

 

8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.
Joint CREPC / SPSC Meeting

 

 

Emerald Ballroom
Tuesday, April 3
8:00 a.m. - 5:15 p.m.

 

 

7:00 a.m.

Continental Breakfast

8:00 a.m.

Call to order / introductions / review agenda

   ·          John Savage, Chair
Remarks by FERC Chair Jon Wellinghoff

8:30 a.m.

Natural gas-electricity interface in the West

     Key issues:
         ·         What actions can improve the coordination of scheduling and
                communication between gas and electric interface?
         ·          Do we need more gas storage in the West, particularly to integrate
               variable generation and accommodate new gas generation?
         ·         What actions (standards, pricing policies) are needed by industry?
                By FERC?  By states/provinces?

     FERC's interests - Commissioner John Norris

         ·          Panel discussion on perspectives on key issues

        o Kurt Longo, Commissioner LaFleur's advisor

        o Catherine Elder, Aspen Environmental Group [pdf]

        o Judah Rose, ICF [pdf]
        o Jim Lobdell, Portland General Electric  [pdf]
     Identification of CREPC-SPSC priorities and next steps [pdf]   ACTION  ITEM 
Background
     Staff paper on key issues
     FERC proposes to Update Standards for Business Practices for Interstate Gas Pipelines
          news release | Commissioners' statements: Norris and LaFleur | NOPR
     FERC Assigns Docket No. to Coordination between Natural Gas and Electricity Markets
     issues Notice   |
     Elder: Implications of natural gas and electricity's convergence: January 25, 2012
     presentation
     ICF paper on integrating variable generation & gas infrastructure, November 22, 2011
     

10:15 a.m.

Break

10:30 a.m.

MIT report on The Future of the Electric Grid - Solutions to:
        ·          New transmission technology development
        ·          Cost  allocation for new transmission
        ·          Integration of variable generation
       o Richard Schmalensee, / John Kassakian, MIT (by phone) (waiting for approval to post)
Background
     MIT Study:  The Future of the Electric Grid
                   Chapter 2: Enhancing the Transmission Network and System Operations
                   Chapter 3: Integration of Variable Energy Resources
                   Chapter 4: Transmission Expansion 

11:30 a.m.

Lunch

1:00 p.m.

Energy Imbalance Market
     Report of the PUC EIM group - Jason Marks (NM) [pdf
     Other developments
        ·          Discussions by the Northwest Power Pool
       o Elliot Mainzer, BPA [pdf]
        ·          Western Systems Power Pool
       o Arnold Podgorsky, WSPP  [pdf]
        ·          Colorado and Nevada EIM dockets
       o Jim Tarpey / Rebecca Wagner
Background
     PUC EIM group overview
     Draft PUC EIM Group Strawman Market Design
     Draft Strawman Market Design comments and responses
     Links to webinars
     WSPP whitepaper on EIM governance
     Colorado PUC docket; Docket number:  11M-998E
     Nevada PUC docket; “Search by Dkt#” | left side |  Docket number:  11-04025
2:00 p.m. Integration of variable generation
     Staff update on actions since October meeting [pdf]  
        ·          Victoria Ravenscroft, WIEB
     WGA draft white paper | executive summary
        ·          Lisa Schwartz, Regulatory Assistance Project [pdf]
        Technical advisors
            o Michael Milligan, NREL
            o Kevin Porter, Exeter Associates

3:00 p.m.

Break

3:15 p.m.

Response to WGA draft white paper and Western industry actions 
        ·          Travis Kavulla, moderator
        Panelists
            o Mason Emnett, FERC
            o Elliot Mainzer, BPA
            o Steve Beuning, Xcel Energy
            o Neil Millar, CAISO

4:30 p.m.

Staff proposal for internet dashboard on variable generation integration [pdf]  ACTION ITEM

4:45 p.m.

Transmission permitting, including federal Rapid Response Transmission Team work
     Report by WGA consultants
       o Larry Chaset, Keyes & Fox [pdf]
     Feedback from CREPC/SPSC members

5:15 p.m.

Recess

 

 

Emerald Ballroom
Wednesday, April 4
8:00 a.m. - 3:00 p.m.

 

7:00 a.m.

Continental Breakfast

8:00 a.m.

Implementation of FERC Order 1000

        ·       What is the footprint of the Subregional Planning Groups (SPGs)? 
        ·       What is the governance of each of the SPGs?
        ·       What is the state role in the development phase leading to compliance filings?
        ·       What is the state role during implementation? 
        ·       Will public power participate?
        ·       What are the SPG plans regarding:
                 a. incorporating public policy requirements,
                 b. determining projects for plans and cost allocation,
                 c. defining benefits, and
                 d. allocating costs
              Report of the CREPC/SPSC Order 1000 Task Force
          o Jim Tarpey, Chair [pdf]
             Panel on key issues
        ·          Moderators | Jim Tarpey, (CO PUC) and Ric Campbell, (UT PSC)
      Panelists   
                                 ■ Mike McLaughlin, FERC
                                 Jeff Goltz, WA
                                 Brian DeKiep, MT
                                 Jason Marks, NM
                                 Rebecca Wagner, NV
                                 Michel Florio, CA
                                 John Phillips, PSE
                                 Jeff Miller, ColumbiaGrid
                                 Rich Bayless, NTTG
                                 Neil Millar, CAISO
                                 Susan Henderson, Xcel Energy
                                 Charlie Pottey, NVEnergy (invited)
                                 Ronald Steinbach, Tri-State G&T
                                 Ravi Aggarwal, BPA
                                 Barry Huddleston, Clean Line Energy Partners
             Potential next steps by states/provinces - Jim Tarpey [pdf]
Background
     CREPC/SPSC Order 1000 Task Force
          Governance Whitepaper
          Cost Allocation Whitepaper
          Public Policy Requirements Whitepaper
     NTTG website
     WestConnect website
     ColumbiaGrid website
        See ColumbiaGrid calendar for Order 1000 meetings; next scheduled meetings are March 13 and April 10.
     California ISO website

10:15 a.m.

Break

10:30 a.m.

Potpourri of recent developments
        ·       Review of WREZ 3 report recommendations related to CREPC and SPSC [pdfACTION  ITEM 
          o Lisa Schwartz, RAP 
          o Doug Larson, WIEB 
        ·       Staff report on development of the Transmission Technology Forum [pdf]
        SPSC consulting proposal  ACTION  ITEM 
          o Doug Larson, WIEB
        ·       Staff report on ideas for 2012 Resource Planners' Forum [pdf]
        SPSC consulting proposal  ACTION  ITEM 
          o Steve Ellenbecker, WIEB
Background
     WREZ Phase 3 Report: executive summary | full report

11:15 a.m.

Report by DOE
        o Larry Mansueti, Office of Electricity
Background
     Secretary Chu memo on power marketing administrations role

11:30 a.m.

Working lunch

11:45 a.m.

Value of wind, PV, and CSP (w/ and w/o storage) at increasing penetration levels
        o Andrew Mills | Galen Barbose, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory [pdf
Background
     March 21 webinar: slides | recording

11:55 a.m.

WECC 10-year transmission planning studies [pdf]
        ·       2012 Study Requests
        ·       Testing the robustness of the transmission grid
          o Brad Nickell, WECC
Background
     SPSC 2012 study requests
     All 2012 study requests to TEPPC:  web submission | original docs

12:25 p.m.

WECC 20-year transmission planning studies [pdf]
        ·       Long-term planning tool demonstration
          o Brad Nickell, WECC
        ·       20-year studies and scenarios
        WECC Scenario Planning Steering Group (SPSG) studies
        SPSC studies
          o Brad Nickell, WECC
        ·       DSM inputs into 20-year transmission studies, including independent load forecast [pdf]
          o Rebecca Wagner, NV, Chair, SPSC DSM Workgroup 
          o Galen Barbose, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 
Background
     Draft SPSG 20 year scenarios

1:45 p.m.

SPSC consulting fund proposals - Staff summary memo [pdf]
     Proposed action items:
          MORE Power Review Group Report
          o Steve Ellenbecker, WIEB [pdf]   ACTION  ITEM 
          Historical grid use analysis tool
          o Victoria Ravenscroft [pdf] ACTION  ITEM 
          Transmission Technology Forum [pdf]
          Dashboard on VER integration actions
     Staff reports on other consulting proposals:
          Transmission planning improvements outside the Western Interconnection
          o DOE activities, Jay Caspary (by phone) [pdf]
          Institutional obstacles to efficient grid use
Background
     MORE Power Review Group Report [pdf]
     Draft language for RFP on historical grid use tool [pdf]

SPSC budget report [pdf]
          o Doug Larson, WIEB

3:00 p.m.

Adjourn