Agenda
|
|
Westin Hotel |
|
San Diego, California |
|
April 3-4, 2012 |
|
|
| Schedule of Meetings | ||||
|
|
Emerald
Ballroom |
|
7:00 a.m. |
Continental Breakfast |
|
8:00 a.m. |
Call to order / introductions / review agenda |
| · John Savage, Chair | |
| Remarks by FERC Chair Jon Wellinghoff | |
|
8:30 a.m. |
Natural gas-electricity interface in the West |
| Key issues: | |
| · What actions can improve the coordination of scheduling and | |
| communication between gas and electric interface? | |
| · Do we need more gas storage in the West, particularly to integrate | |
| variable generation and accommodate new gas generation? | |
| · What actions (standards, pricing policies) are needed by industry? | |
| By FERC? By states/provinces? | |
| FERC's interests - Commissioner John Norris | |
| · Panel discussion on perspectives on key issues | |
| o Kurt Longo, Commissioner LaFleur's advisor | |
| o Catherine Elder, Aspen Environmental Group [pdf] | |
| o Judah Rose, ICF [pdf] | |
| o Jim Lobdell, Portland General Electric [pdf] | |
| Identification of CREPC-SPSC priorities and next steps [pdf] ACTION ITEM | |
| Background | |
| Staff paper on key issues | |
| FERC proposes to Update Standards for Business Practices for Interstate Gas Pipelines | |
|
news
release | Commissioners' statements: Norris
and LaFleur
| NOPR
|
|
| FERC Assigns Docket No. to Coordination between Natural Gas and Electricity Markets | |
| issues Notice
|
|
| Elder: Implications of natural gas and electricity's convergence: January 25, 2012 | |
| presentation | |
| ICF paper on integrating variable generation & gas infrastructure, November 22, 2011 | |
|
10:15 a.m. |
Break |
|
10:30 a.m. |
MIT report on The Future of the Electric Grid - Solutions to: |
| · New transmission technology development | |
| · Cost allocation for new transmission | |
| · Integration of variable generation | |
| o Richard Schmalensee, / John Kassakian, MIT (by phone) (waiting for approval to post) | |
| Background | |
| MIT Study: The Future of the Electric Grid | |
| ♦ Chapter 2: Enhancing the Transmission Network and System Operations | |
| ♦ Chapter 3: Integration of Variable Energy Resources | |
| ♦ Chapter 4: Transmission Expansion | |
|
11:30 a.m. |
Lunch |
|
1:00 p.m. |
Energy Imbalance Market |
| Report of the PUC EIM group - Jason Marks (NM) [pdf] | |
| Other developments | |
| · Discussions by the Northwest Power Pool | |
| o Elliot Mainzer, BPA [pdf] | |
| · Western Systems Power Pool | |
| o Arnold Podgorsky, WSPP [pdf] | |
| · Colorado and Nevada EIM dockets | |
| o Jim Tarpey / Rebecca Wagner | |
| Background | |
| PUC EIM group overview | |
| Draft PUC EIM Group Strawman Market Design | |
| Draft Strawman Market Design comments and responses | |
| Links to webinars | |
| WSPP whitepaper on EIM governance | |
| Colorado PUC docket; Docket number: 11M-998E | |
| Nevada PUC docket; “Search by Dkt#” | left side | Docket number: 11-04025 | |
| 2:00 p.m. | Integration of variable generation |
| Staff update on actions since October meeting [pdf] | |
| · Victoria Ravenscroft, WIEB | |
| WGA draft white paper | executive summary | |
| · Lisa Schwartz, Regulatory Assistance Project [pdf] | |
| ♦ Technical advisors | |
| o Michael Milligan, NREL | |
| o Kevin Porter, Exeter Associates | |
|
3:00 p.m. |
Break |
|
3:15 p.m. |
Response to WGA draft white paper and Western industry actions |
| · Travis Kavulla, moderator | |
| ♦ Panelists | |
| o Mason Emnett, FERC | |
| o Elliot Mainzer, BPA | |
| o Steve Beuning, Xcel Energy | |
| o Neil Millar, CAISO | |
|
4:30 p.m. |
Staff proposal for internet dashboard on variable generation integration [pdf] ACTION ITEM |
|
4:45 p.m. |
Transmission permitting, including federal Rapid Response Transmission Team work |
| Report by WGA consultants | |
| o Larry Chaset, Keyes & Fox [pdf] | |
| Feedback from CREPC/SPSC members | |
|
5:15 p.m. |
Recess |
|
Emerald
Ballroom |
|
7:00 a.m. |
Continental Breakfast |
|
8:00 a.m. |
Implementation of FERC Order 1000 |
| · What is the footprint of the Subregional Planning Groups (SPGs)? | |
| · What is the governance of each of the SPGs? | |
| · What is the state role in the development phase leading to compliance filings? | |
| · What is the state role during implementation? | |
| · Will public power participate? | |
| · What are the SPG plans regarding: | |
| a. incorporating public policy requirements, | |
| b. determining projects for plans and cost allocation, | |
| c. defining benefits, and | |
| d. allocating costs | |
| Report of the CREPC/SPSC Order 1000 Task Force | |
| o Jim Tarpey, Chair [pdf] | |
| Panel on key issues | |
| · Moderators | Jim Tarpey, (CO PUC) and Ric Campbell, (UT PSC) | |
| Panelists | |
| ■ Mike McLaughlin, FERC | |
| ■ Jeff Goltz, WA | |
| ■ Brian DeKiep, MT | |
| ■ Jason Marks, NM | |
| ■ Rebecca Wagner, NV | |
| ■ Michel Florio, CA | |
| ■ John Phillips, PSE | |
| ■ Jeff Miller, ColumbiaGrid | |
| ■ Rich Bayless, NTTG | |
| ■ Neil Millar, CAISO | |
| ■ Susan Henderson, Xcel Energy | |
| ■ Charlie Pottey, NVEnergy (invited) | |
| ■ Ronald Steinbach, Tri-State G&T | |
| ■ Ravi Aggarwal, BPA | |
| ■ Barry Huddleston, Clean Line Energy Partners | |
| Potential next steps by states/provinces - Jim Tarpey [pdf] | |
| Background | |
| CREPC/SPSC Order 1000 Task Force | |
| Governance Whitepaper | |
| Cost Allocation Whitepaper | |
| Public Policy Requirements Whitepaper | |
| NTTG website | |
| WestConnect website | |
| ColumbiaGrid website | |
|
See ColumbiaGrid calendar for Order 1000 meetings; next
scheduled meetings are March 13 and April 10. |
|
| California ISO website | |
|
10:15 a.m. |
Break |
|
10:30 a.m. |
Potpourri of recent developments |
| · Review of WREZ 3 report recommendations related to CREPC and SPSC [pdf] ACTION ITEM | |
| o Lisa Schwartz, RAP | |
| o Doug Larson, WIEB | |
| · Staff report on development of the Transmission Technology Forum [pdf] | |
| ♦ SPSC consulting proposal ACTION ITEM | |
| o Doug Larson, WIEB | |
| · Staff report on ideas for 2012 Resource Planners' Forum [pdf] | |
| ♦ SPSC consulting proposal ACTION ITEM | |
| o Steve Ellenbecker, WIEB | |
| Background | |
| WREZ Phase 3 Report: executive summary | full report | |
|
11:15 a.m. |
Report by DOE |
| o Larry Mansueti, Office of Electricity | |
| Background | |
| Secretary Chu memo on power marketing administrations role | |
|
11:30 a.m. |
Working lunch |
|
11:45 a.m. |
Value of wind, PV, and CSP (w/ and w/o storage) at increasing penetration levels |
| o Andrew Mills | Galen Barbose, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory [pdf] | |
| Background | |
| March 21 webinar: slides | recording | |
|
11:55 a.m. |
WECC 10-year transmission planning studies [pdf] |
| · 2012 Study Requests | |
| · Testing the robustness of the transmission grid | |
| o Brad Nickell, WECC | |
| Background | |
| SPSC 2012 study requests | |
| All 2012 study requests to TEPPC: web submission | original docs | |
|
12:25 p.m. |
WECC 20-year transmission planning studies [pdf] |
| · Long-term planning tool demonstration | |
| o Brad Nickell, WECC | |
| · 20-year studies and scenarios | |
| ♦ WECC Scenario Planning Steering Group (SPSG) studies | |
| ♦ SPSC studies | |
| o Brad Nickell, WECC | |
| · DSM inputs into 20-year transmission studies, including independent load forecast [pdf] | |
| o Rebecca Wagner, NV, Chair, SPSC DSM Workgroup | |
| o Galen Barbose, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory | |
| Background | |
| Draft SPSG 20 year scenarios | |
|
1:45 p.m. |
SPSC consulting fund proposals - Staff summary memo [pdf] |
| Proposed action items: | |
| MORE Power Review Group Report | |
| o Steve Ellenbecker, WIEB [pdf] ACTION ITEM | |
| Historical grid use analysis tool | |
| o Victoria Ravenscroft [pdf] ACTION ITEM | |
| Transmission Technology Forum [pdf] | |
| Dashboard on VER integration actions | |
| Staff reports on other consulting proposals: | |
| Transmission planning improvements outside the Western Interconnection | |
| o DOE activities, Jay Caspary (by phone) [pdf] | |
| Institutional obstacles to efficient grid use | |
| Background | |
| MORE Power Review Group Report [pdf] | |
| Draft language for RFP on historical grid use tool [pdf] | |
| SPSC budget report [pdf] | |
| o Doug Larson, WIEB | |
|
3:00 p.m. |
Adjourn |