|
Agenda |
| casual attire (no ties) |
|
Marines Memorial Club and Hotel |
|
San Francisco, California |
|
March 24-26, 2004 |
|
Agenda |
| Schedule of Meetings |
| Wednesday March 24, 2004 | Thursday March 25, 2004 | Friday March 26, 2004 |
| 1:00
p.m. - 4:00 p.m. CREPC workshop HERITAGE ROOM |
8:30
a.m. - 5:30 p.m. CREPC meeting COMMANDANTS ROOM |
8:30
a.m. - 1:00 p.m. CREPC meeting COMMANDANTS ROOM |
|
Wednesday, March 24, 2004 |
| 1:00 p.m. | Workshop on WesTTrans (a common OASIS and energy bulletin board) |
| Jerry Smith, Arizona Public Service | |
| Charlie Reinhold, wesTTrans | |
| Questions: | |
|
· How does the system work? |
|
|
· Which control areas are participating? |
|
|
· How much does wesTTrans cost and how is it financed? |
|
|
·
Does the system include an energy
market or posting of power offers? |
|
|
· Who will calculate ATC?
Transmission owners? Independent
entity? |
|
|
·
Will there be any auditing of TTC and
ATC calculations? By whom? |
|
|
·
What, if any, additional existing
transmission capacity will be freed-up by a common OASIS? |
|
|
·
When will unscheduled transmission
capacity be released for others to use? |
|
|
·
Will the OASIS support new transmission
products, such as quasi-firm transmission? |
|
|
·
Will the OASIS system catalogue and
archive hourly TTC and ATC to permit comparisons |
|
|
·
Will there be any effort to link
wesTTrans and non-participating control areas so as to |
|
|
·
How does wesTTrans compare with the
incremental proposals being developed by the |
|
| Background information | |
| WesTTrans presentation | |
| WesTTrans OASIS executive overview | |
| Powerpoint presentation on wesTTrans | |
| WesTTrans executive summary | |
| Adjourn westTTrans workshop | |
| Meeting of CREPC’s Regional Decision-Making Work Group | |
| Adjourn work group meeting | |
| Thursday, March 25, 2004 |
| 7:30 a.m. | Continental breakfast |
| 8:30 a.m. | Convene meeting |
| Report from the Chair |
|
|
·
|
|
| 9:00 a.m. | Developments at FERC |
| · Suedeen Kelly, Commissioner | |
| Background information | |
| NARUC table on FERC and court decision | |
| Canadian perspective on Reliability Standards | |
| Alberta perspective on Reliability Standards | |
| Regional electricity decision-making | |
|
· Developments in other regions |
|
|
o Bob Anderson (RAP) |
|
|
o Greg Jergeson (MT PSC) |
|
|
· Reports from work groups |
|
|
o
Reliability – |
|
|
o Resource assessment/adequacy – Grace Anderson (CEC) |
|
|
o
Market monitoring – |
|
|
o
Transmission planning and expansion – |
|
|
o Transmission permitting – John Savage (OR PUC) |
|
|
· Proposed recommendations to Western Governors |
|
|
o
Regional decision-making work group – |
|
|
o Discussion (with decision on next steps being made on Friday) |
|
| Questions | |
|
·
What recommendations should be made to
Western governors? |
|
|
·
What are the next steps in developing
recommendations to Western governors? |
|
|
·
What are the key unanswered questions? |
|
| Background information | |
| Reliability Work Group report | |
| West-wide Resource Assessment Team report | |
| Market Monitoring Work Group report | |
| Transmission Planning and Expansion Work Group report
& RAP background paper |
|
| Transmission Permitting Work Group report | |
| Regional Decision-Making Work Group report | |
| Regional Q&A | |
| B. Anderson presentation | |
| Chamberlain presentation | |
| G. Anderson presentation | |
| Break | |
| 11:15 a.m. | Status and direction of the RTO West effort |
|
· Bud Krogh, RTO West / Wally Gibson, NWPCC |
|
|
·
CREPC participants in RRG ( |
|
| Background information | |
| RRG Proposal - short briefing paper | |
| RRG Proposal | |
| Krogh presentation | |
| 12:15 p.m. | Lunch – on your own |
| 1:45 p.m. | Western resource assessment and adequacy |
|
· Continuing Data and Assessment Needs |
|
| o Confidentiality and Load Forecasts | |
| o Generation Expansion Cases and IRP/State Policies | |
| o Integrated System Risk Assessment | |
|
· Emerging Resource Adequacy Considerations |
|
|
o Resource Adequacy Challenges, Wally Gibson |
|
|
o Approaches to Resource Adequacy, Grace Anderson/Mike Jaske |
|
|
o Reserves Concepts - Definitions and Metrics, Chuck Goldman, LBL |
|
|
o Regional Resource Adequacy Criteria, Louise McCarren, WECC |
|
|
· Discussion and Next Steps |
|
| Questions | |
|
· How do we know if we are again heading into a period of tight supply? |
|
|
· What needs to be done? |
|
|
· What should CREPC push for? Better
resource assessments? |
|
|
· What's the risk of doing nothing? |
|
| Background Information | |
| WRAT Final Briefing Paper | |
| WRAT Attachments to Briefing Paper | |
| WRAT Risk Assessment Framework | |
| G. Anderson presentation | |
| Jaske presentation | |
| 3:30 p.m. | Break |
| 4:00 p.m. | |
|
· Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory – Chuck Goldman/Galen Barbose - Overview |
|
|
· Selected reports on status of LSE resource plans and acquisition |
|
|
o
What process are PG&E/SCE/Sempra
using to acquire new resources and assure |
|
|
o What are the loads and resources of major
LSEs that do not do resource plans? |
|
|
o Do any states/provinces review public
power resource plans? |
|
| Background Information | |
| CA procurement - Decision 04-01-050 | |
| Weissman presentation | |
| Jaske presentation | |
| Fluckiger presentation | |
| 5:00 p.m. | Demand Response in the West |
| · Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory – Chuck Goldman/Galen Barbose | |
| · Roundtable on DR in western states | |
|
o
Do any states/provinces believe
proposed demand response measures are adequate? |
|
| Background Information | |
| Past Western LSE demand response programs | |
| Barbose presentation on IRP's | |
| Goldman presentation on Demand Response | |
| 5:30 p.m. | Recess |
| Friday, March 26, 2004 |
| 7:30 a.m. | Continental breakfast |
| 8:30 a.m. | FERC's efforts to share market analysis/data with Western states |
| · George Godding, FERC | |
| · Lou Ann Westerfield, CREPC Marketing Monitoring Work Group | |
| Questions: | |
|
·
What information can OMOI share with
Western states today? |
|
|
·
What actions are needed to expand the
sharing of information? |
|
|
·
What are the impediments to taking such
actions? |
|
|
·
What is the most effective means to
communicate market performance information |
|
|
·
What do states need to do to receive
market sensitive information? |
|
| Background information | |
| PJM proposal to FERC on state access to confidential market data | |
| Model PJM Non-Disclosure Agreement | |
| Review of Market Monitoring Activities at U.S. Independent System Operators, LBL | |
| Godding presentation | |
| Western transmission planning | |
|
· Next steps by SSG-WI - Dean Perry |
|
|
· Sub-regional planning |
|
|
o RMATS - Steve Ellenbecker, Wyoming Governors' Office |
|
|
o STEP - Jeff Miller, California ISO |
|
|
o NTAC - Chris Reese, Puget Sound Energy |
|
|
o CATS/SWAT - Charlie Reinhold |
|
|
· Other |
|
|
o Nevada transmission for wind study - Kirby Lampley, Nevada PSC |
|
|
o California PIER transmission study - Tim Tutt |
|
| Questions: | |
|
·
What’s the status of planning in each
sub-region? |
|
|
·
What are the major transmission
expansion ideas emerging from the planning? |
|
|
·
Are there other transmission proposals
not being incorporated into the planning |
|
|
·
What progress is being made to ensure
the development of a common, public database |
|
|
·
Is the information from LSE resource
plans submitted to PUCs being used in |
|
|
·
Do the transmission plans consider
non-transmission alternatives and new transmission |
|
|
·
How are LSE resource plans considered
in regional and sub-regional transmission |
|
| Background information | |
| Perry presentation | |
| RMATS | |
| STEP [Miller presentation] | |
| NTAC [Reese presentation] | |
| CATS/SWAT | |
| Nevada transmission for wind study [Lampley presentation] | |
| PIER [Tutt presentation] | |
| 10:45 a.m. | Break |
|
Utility of the Western Renewable Energy
Generation Information |
|
| Questions |
|
|
· Why should
tracking and registration of renewable energy generation and renewable |
|
|
o
Will WREGIS
enable states/provinces to verify utility compliance with |
|
|
o
Will WREGIS
enable states/provinces with information disclosure requirements |
|
|
o
How do
renewable energy certificates intersect with utility rate-making? |
|
|
·
What do PUCs
need to do to ensure WREGIS will meet their needs? |
|
|
o
What PUC
administered programs or mandates could
be served by WREGIS? |
|
|
o
How can
regulators have input into the development of WREGIS? |
|
|
·
What are the
next steps in the development of WREGIS? |
|
|
o
Where will
WREGIS be housed? |
|
|
o
How will
WREGIS be financed? |
|
|
o
When will
WREGIS be operational? |
|
| Background information | |
| WREGIS web site | |
| Burks-Hamrin presentation | |
| 11:30 a.m. | Business meeting |
|
·
Next steps on recommendations to Western
Governors on regional electricity |
|
| · Status of WECC Class 5 elections | |
|
· Other |
|
| Adjourn | |